| The original setup: enter when price pulls back to a moving average, then bounces back up strongly. The released version checks every hour of the trading week. | Identical to Classic Pullback, with one thing relaxed: price only needs to pull back CLOSE to the moving average (not touch it exactly) to count. | Also Classic Pullback, with the pullback condition relaxed a different way: it now counts if ANY of the last 3 bars (not just the one right before) touched the moving average. | Same entry condition as Classic Pullback, but with NO cap on simultaneously open trades, and it locks in break-even sooner, at just +1R. | Completely different from the other four: it only looks at ONE moment per day — fixed at 07:00 UTC all year. That matches the London open during UK summer time (BST), but in winter London opens at 08:00 UTC. | Exactly Every Signal, with one difference: at most 3 trades open at once instead of 20. Before 10 Oct 2026 this site called it research candidate FWD-01. |
|---|
| Entry conditions | - Checks every hour of the trading week — the released version applies no session filter.
- Trend is strong enough (ADX14 ≥ 22) and the moving average is clearly sloping up.
- Recent price range is wide enough relative to typical daily movement (measured by ATR14).
- Higher timeframes (H1, H4) also confirm the uptrend.
- The prior bar touched or dipped into the EMA34/EMA89 zone — i.e. a pullback just happened.
- The signal bar closes green, bouncing back above the EMA34/EMA89 zone.
- Daily stop rule hasn't triggered, and there's room to open a new trade.
| - Every Classic Pullback condition, except the pullback condition.
- A pullback now counts if price touches the moving average as before, OR gets within a small distance of it (based on ATR14) — a 'near miss' also qualifies.
| - Every Classic Pullback condition, except the pullback condition.
- A pullback now counts if at least 1 of the last 3 bars touched or dipped into its own moving-average zone.
| - Identical entry condition to Classic Pullback.
- The only difference: every valid signal opens a trade — no cap on open trades the way Classic Pullback has (just a 20-trade technical safety ceiling).
| - Only evaluates one moment per day: 7:00 UTC, Monday through Friday.
- The higher timeframe (H4) confirms an uptrend.
- The EMA34 moving average is sloping up strongly enough relative to recent volatility.
| - Identical to Every Signal (i.e. Classic Pullback's entry conditions), with all the same thresholds.
- The only difference: with 3 trades already open, new signals are skipped.
|
|---|
| Initial stop-loss | Set just below the EMA89 at the signal bar, offset by a distance based on ATR14 (recent volatility). | Same as Classic Pullback. | Same as Classic Pullback. | Same as Classic Pullback. | Set just below the EMA89 at 7:00, entering at the open 15 minutes later. | Same as Classic Pullback. |
|---|
| How the stop-loss trails | - At +2R profit ⇒ move the stop-loss to the entry price (break-even).
- At +3R ⇒ move it up to lock in +1R.
- At +4R ⇒ move it up to lock in +2R, and so on: each new whole-R level locks in one more R.
- The stop only ever moves tighter, never looser.
| - Identical to Classic Pullback's ladder (lock break-even at +2R, then +1R per whole R level after).
| - Identical to Classic Pullback.
| - At +1R profit ⇒ move the stop-loss to break-even (one level earlier than Classic Pullback).
- At +3R ⇒ move it up to lock in +1R.
- At +4R ⇒ move it up to lock in +2R, and so on: each new whole-R level locks in one more R.
| - Identical to Classic Pullback's ladder (lock break-even at +2R, then +1R per whole R level after).
| - Identical to Every Signal: at +1R the stop moves to break-even.
- At +3R it locks in +1R, then each further R moves it up another 1R.
|
|---|
| Max open trades | Up to 3 trades open at the same time. | Up to 3 trades open at the same time. | Up to 3 trades open at the same time. | No design limit (backtests peaked at 13 simultaneous trades on Exness, 19 on Dukascopy); the EA enforces a technical cap of 20. | Up to 3 trades open at the same time. | At most 3 trades open at once. |
|---|
| Daily stop rule | Count closed trades with pnl ≤ 0 by UTC day; once 2 losses are reached, no new trade opens for the rest of that day. | Count closed trades with pnl ≤ 0 by UTC day; once 2 losses are reached, no new trade opens for the rest of that day. | Count closed trades with pnl ≤ 0 by UTC day; once 2 losses are reached, no new trade opens for the rest of that day. | Count closed trades with pnl ≤ 0 by UTC day; once 2 losses are reached, no new trade opens for the rest of that day. | Count closed trades with pnl ≤ 0 by UTC day; once 2 losses are reached, no new trade opens for the rest of that day. | Count closed trades with pnl ≤ 0 by UTC day; once 2 losses are reached, no new trade opens for the rest of that day. |
|---|
| Known weaknesses | - Statistically, a true edge of zero can't be ruled out yet.
- Most of the profit comes from a handful of big-trend trades — drop the best 10 and the average falls to just +0.07R/trade (measured on the filtered version; not yet measured for 24/7).
- Formal statistical validation of the 24/7 version (RL-13, 2026-09-20): FAILED — Holm-adjusted p-value 0.128, threshold p < 0.05.
| - This relaxed condition was chosen AFTER trying about 140 different variants and seeing which numbers looked good — a risk of having picked the best-looking one by chance, despite passing a few robustness checks.
- Preliminary checks looked promising, but the formal validation that followed still failed (see below).
- Formal statistical validation of the 24/7 version (RL-13, 2026-09-20): FAILED — Holm-adjusted p-value 0.128, threshold p < 0.05.
| - Also chosen after scanning a wide parameter grid — the same selection risk as Near-Touch Pullback.
- Preliminary checks looked promising, but the formal validation that followed still failed (see below).
- Formal statistical validation of the 24/7 version (RL-13, 2026-09-20): FAILED — Holm-adjusted p-value 0.128, threshold p < 0.05.
| - The most width-sensitive of the group: widening the dragon-band threshold by 1.25× cuts average profit by 43%.
- No cap on open trades means many can lose together during a sharp move; backtest drawdown has exceeded the buffer of many prop-firm accounts.
- Formal statistical validation of the 24/7 version (RL-13, 2026-09-20): FAILED — Holm-adjusted p-value 0.128, threshold p < 0.05.
| - Formal statistical validation (RL-11): FAILED — Holm-adjusted p-value 0.064, threshold p < 0.05.
- Sensitive to the stop distance: tightening it 25% cuts average profit by 38%. Drop the best 10 trades and it turns negative (Exness 2016–2023).
- Very few trades per year (around 40) — many years of data would be needed to draw a firm conclusion.
| - Formal test RL-14: declared alone it passed (Holm p 0.0338); declared with the other 4 it FAILED (Holm p 0.1605) — on the same 1,046 trades. It was picked AFTER reading RL-13's results, against about 130 exploratory configurations, so the “pass” is not evidence.
- The 2024 → Aug 2026 holdout came out SURVIVES but is not clean: the period had been seen before the pick, and gold rose strongly through it — good conditions for a trend-following strategy.
- The formal test on the frozen Dukascopy dataset once showed about half the edge (+0.143 to +0.160R vs +0.277R on Exness). The cause has been found: that dataset is missing 706 weekdays in 2016–2023; on continuous Dukascopy data the result matches Exness (+0.241R vs +0.251R).
- MT5 2018 lost −$2,756 (55-trade losing streak); the continuous 2018 → Aug 2026 run drew down up to $3,123 at $50/trade — close to the $4,000 room of a 50K prop account.
|
|---|